My Canuck's hockey team lost last night in a shoot-out and is now in 7th place (only 8 teams make the playoffs). For those of you familiar with Canadian sports, hockey ranks number 1 in our sports culture, while it ranks somewhere after monster truck racing in the
On different note, I received a few emails from readers commenting on last week's eNewsletter and the In The News story about A School That's Too High on Gizmos. Many commented both ways; some felt that technology was critical to a sound education, while others felt that it was only 1 of many tools to support the learning process, and emphasis should be placed on reading, writing, and arithmetic.
Today in my eNewsletter I am going to spend time looking at the computer in education and whether it really helps students learn.
Enjoy the eNewsletter,
Doug Halladay
President and Founder
Halladay Education Group Inc.
www.HalladayEducationGroup.com
================================
In This Issue
================================
1. In The News
2. Services That Your School Needs
3. Do Computers Help Students?
4. Products To Invest In To Start And Manage Your School
==================================
1. In The News
==================================
New Christian education that's decidedly old
Douglas Wilson, one of the founders of Logos, observes that outside CCE circles "most conservative private schools have a sense of church history that goes ...
RedOrbit -
But many educators believe the existence of solid private schools helps to raise the bar for teachers and pupils throughout the area. ...
Hawaii private schools raising tuition fees
Tuition at major private schools in
==================================
2. Services That Your School Needs
==================================
>>> (1) Strategic Planning
Do you want a plan to improve your school? Then your School needs a Strategic Plan. I can facilitate the development of your comprehensive Plan that will build consensus and motivate support and define critical priorities and strategic for your Board and Administration to improve your school.
Click on the following link to download my brochure on our Strategic Planning process, or call me at 1-604-868-0002, or email me at info@halladayeducationgroup.com Click on the following link to download my firm’s brochure outlining Strategic Planning services:
http://www.halladayeducationgroup.com/File/heg_strategic_planning_services-1.pdf
>>> (2) BOARD GOVERNANCE WORKSHOPS
Do you want your private school or non-profit to be more successful in board governance? If so, my full-day governance workshop and online survey helps your trustees to fine-tune their performance and refocus their mandate. Please email me at info@halladayeducationgroup.com or call us at 604-868-0002 to find out more about how we can help you. Click on the following link to download my brochure
>>> (3) STARTING YOUR OWN SCHOOL
Starting a private school can be very challenging and you never have a 2nd chance to make a first impression. This is why you need a firm that has experience starting schools in
1. One-Day Comprehensive Overview Session
2. Formal Feasibility Study
3. Detailed Business Plan Development
4.
6. Ongoing Consulting Services
7. Ongoing Management and Operations Services
If you would like more information about my services and range of fees related to help start your school, please call me at 1-604-868-0002, email me at info@halladayeducationgroup.com, or click on the following link to download my brochure outlining our services and fees:
http://www.halladayeducationgroup.com/File/Overview_School_Formation_Fees_Services.pdf
==================================
3. Do Computers Help Students?
==================================
What tweaked today’s article was the response to an article in last week’s eNewsletter about a new public school in Philadelphia that had spent millions on every cutting-edge technology on the market, yet many of the staff felt demoralized about their ability to teach. Many of my
Some of you may know that my professional background included a 3 year stint as a Senior Curriculum and Resources Coordinator with BC’s Ministry of Education. In this role I led the development of about 20 percent of the province’s K-12 curriculum, known as IRP’s. Two of the IRP’s I am proud to have developed were Technology Education and Information Technology. At the time, both cutting-edge curricular guides for teachers using and teaching technology as a means and end.
As I was reflecting on their comments and viewpoints on technology in education, I came across another article in the February 27/08 National Post with the headline, “Computer Use May Not Help Students.” I am going to share some excerpts from the article to provide some more thought on computers and education.
The article started off with the provocative statement from a report commenting that “filling classrooms with computers does not seem to be making students any smarter and may actually be harming the education of younger children.”
The article referred to a study completed by the Frontier Centre for Public Policy think-tank. It cited several international studies that found students with less access to computers earned higher grades in math, reading, and science.
The author of the report, Michael Zwaagstra, stated that more computer access did not automatically mean a better education…the push to make students computer literate could come at the cost of teaching them such basic subjects as reading by cutting into class time.
He counters that he is not a Luddite trying to say there should not be any computers; just a balance.
His concerns are not at the high school level, but rather at the primary school level. He wonders what is the sense of teaching a Grade 2 how to use a computer when more time and funding could be focused on the basics of reading and math.
His report found that when variables such as household income were considered, students with the most access to computers at home and school had lower scores in math, reading, and science than students with less computer access.
The report concluded that computer use did not increase academic achievement.
As a former classroom teacher and developer of technology-based curriculum, my thought is that it is not the computers fault entirely (or other technology-based learning tools). Yes, foundation skills for literacy and numeracy need to be taught well. However, technology can be used as a tool to enhance and expand learning – just as we use it as a tool in our workplace (like I am doing right now).
The problem lies in not providing enough funding to educate teachers on how to use their technology. You will notice I did not mention spending more money on buying cutting-edge technology. I learned a long time ago that you can never keep up with the technology race, so why try. Just support teachers learning the balance of traditional and computer-based instruction to help children learn better.
If you would like to comment on this eNewsletter, please click on the following link and add your comments on my blog.
---> http://halladayeducationgroupinnercircle.blogspot.com/
================================
4. Products To Invest In To Start And Manage Your School
================================
Do you want effective tools to help start and manage your school? These 2 products can help.
>>>(A). STRATEGIC PLANNING TOOLKIT (#1 BEST SELLER)
Learn How To Develop Your Own Strategic Plan Like The Pro
http://www.halladayeducationgroup.com/products/stratgic_planning_toolkit.php
>>>(B). WEBINAR SERIES – DISCOVER FROM EXPERTS HOW TO START A SCHOOL (#2 BEST SELLER)
Are you still struggling with starting your own for- or non-profit K-12 School, College, University, or Institute? You
1.
2. 9 Secrets To Starting A
3. 8 Golden Rules of Starting a
4. Starting a Successful
5. 10 Steps To A Winning Strategic Plan
6. The Whole Enchilada - All 5 Webinars at 40% Off
Get all the details here:
http://www.halladayeducationgroup.com/products/webinaroverview.php
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
To your success,
Douglas Halladay
President and Founder
Halladay Education Group Inc.
www.HalladayEducationGroup.com
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
P.S. Do not forget to check out our secure Online Store for ways to invest in improving or starting your own school or non-profit. Here is the link:
--> http://www.halladayeducationgroup.com/products/products.php
I am both a computer and educational professional, having degrees in both fields. I have taught science, social studies, math, and computers. I have incorporated computers in my teaching when appropriate (mostly with science and social studies.)
ReplyDeleteI will answer this question in 2 ways. First as a computer teacher, then as a regular teacher.
As a computer teacher, I will say, absolutely not. Computers do not help the student one single bit. Students can now copy and paste willy nilly. Some will say this helps with organization. Oh how great it would be if this were true. I think you can develop just as good as skills in organization the old fashion way, of rewriting something. Students have completely lost the skills of pre-organizing! They couldn't write an outline if their life depended on it. Thus, students spend no time thinking, researching, and organizing, instead, they just plop words down, often copied and pasted from other websites. So, there's my rant, at least in regards to word processing, which is what students primarily use the computer for. They also use it some for presentations. Again, students do the copy paste thing, putting text on any slide they want, or, possibly even worse, on the slide the teacher tells them to put it in (Slide 1: country name, Slide 2: Flag, Slide 3: Foods, Slide 4: Currency.) A teacher telling what slides to put something on is not helping the student learn how to organize.
Of course, there's that whole issue of spelling as well. With spell check, students don't even have to think about their spelling!
In a sense, I think computers have made kids sloppy, unorganized, and in a rush to finish things (e.g., a term paper without computers would take weeks, a term paper with a computer takes 20 minutes of Google, Wikipedia, copy, and paste).
Remember - I'm criticizing this as someone who is a professional in the field. I grew up on computers, I fix them for schools, I program educational materials, etc.
OK, Now as a teacher. For the most part, I still don't think computers are very good. In my educational program, the whole rage was webquests. I have yet to find one that is well designed and really promotes much learning. On the other hand, there are some wonderful interactive sites that can help the student learn or review concepts. I remember a particularly good one on the cell. However, it was more useful as a review than a learning tool. There are some excellent geography based web applications out there as well. So, as a general teacher, I'm mixed. I think it's important that whatever is being done on a computer serves a particular educational purpose. Too often, teachers will have a class use a computer just because they are supposed to utilize technology, without even thinking about the amount of learning that would actually occur, or comparative amount to the learning that could be completed otherwise.